What Costa Rica's REDD+ experience can teach us about social integrity

Lessons on representation, consent and benefit sharing for carbon markets

November 12, 2026
Line of women in colorful dresses waiting at a desk while a man writes at a registration table.

Costa Rica’s experience shows how sustained investment in rights, participation and accountable governance can support credible forest finance.

Photo: UNDP Costa Rica

When UNDP’s REDD+ Results-Based Payments project began supporting Costa Rica’s national REDD+ programme in 2021, the central question concerned people rather than technical design. How could a US$54 million project funded through the Green Climate Fund respect the rights, governance structures and priorities of eight distinct Indigenous Peoples across 24 territories, each with its own history, leadership and relationship to the forest? 

The project joined a national consultation process that Indigenous communities and the Costa Rican government had been building since 2008. It supported efforts to put more than a decade of dialogue and agreements into practice. The project’s Indigenous Peoples Plan guided this work, outlining how communities would participate, how their governance structures would be respected and how risks to their rights would be addressed. UNDP requires this safeguards instrument when a project may affect Indigenous Peoples’ rights, lands, resources or territories. 

A case study in Module 2, Consultation and Consent, of UNDP’s High-Integrity Carbon Markets Toolkit examines this experience. Its lessons reach well beyond Costa Rica. 

Understanding risks and recognizing local governance 

UNDP’s Social and Environmental Screening Procedure identified five risks in the project’s support for the Payment for Environmental Services (PES) Programme in Indigenous Territories. Consultation that bypassed representative organizations could interfere with rights to autonomy and self-determination. Women could face discrimination in decision-making, and benefits could be shared inequitably within communities. Accountability mechanisms could prove inadequate, and conflicts could arise between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people in Indigenous Territories. 

The first risk was already documented. In 2011 and again in 2022, the UN Special Rapporteur on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples raised concerns about the representativeness of Costa Rica’s state-mandated Integral Development Associations (ADIs). Addressing this concern became central to the project’s approach. 

Under Costa Rica’s legal framework, ADIs represent Indigenous Territories and are authorized to enter PES contracts with FONAFIFO, the national forestry fund. Yet governance varied considerably between territories. Some had reshaped ADIs into locally supported governance structures. Elsewhere, traditional authorities operated alongside them, sometimes uneasily. In Térraba, women’s organizations and traditional authorities provided alternative centres of authority, while the ADI’s legitimacy was contested. Quitirrisí had no ADI. 

Our approach began with understanding each territory’s governance before making commitments concerning participation in Forest and Territorial Environmental Plans (PAFTs), which define how REDD+ resources are governed and used. Consultation needed to reach the organizations each territory recognized as representative. 

Where ADIs worked with traditional authorities and community groups, we followed those arrangements. Where their representativeness was contested, we paused, documented concerns and supported dialogue to make space for full and effective participation. 

Putting Indigenous rights and priorities into practice 

Two plans helped translate consultation into practice. The Indigenous Peoples Plan (IPP) set out how the project would engage with Indigenous Peoples across all 24 territories and address risks to their rights. Each PAFT was developed by an individual territory to define how its REDD+ resources would be governed, how benefits would be shared and which community priorities the funds would support. 

The IPP was developed by a team experienced in working with Indigenous Peoples, with specialist legal review on collective rights and international human rights law. Grounded in ILO Convention 169, the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples and the Inter-American human rights system, it responded to the different governance arrangements across Costa Rica’s territories. 

For each identified risk, the IPP set out measures to address it. It also guided engagement through successive stages, beginning with information sharing and an understanding of local governance, followed by dialogue and PAFT development, then community feedback and validation. 

The idea for PAFTs came from the national consultation process and was formalized in its consultation agreement. The project funded their development and linked completion to payments. Each plan documented free, prior and informed consent (FPIC), established benefit-sharing arrangements and set out the territory’s priorities. 

Under the Performance-Based Payment Agreement, territories first had to submit a preparatory agreement to the REDD+ Secretariat, including a letter expressing interest in joining the process. The PAFT that followed required validation at a territorial assembly open to all parties, then review by the project management unit and an independent assessor before payments were made. 

Initially, territories completing a PAFT with governance committees comprising at least 40 percent Indigenous women qualified for a 10 percent bonus payment. From 2023, a validated PAFT became a condition for receiving payments. 

PAFT development began in 2022. The process described in the case study involved approximately US$1 million in investment. Women made up 51 percent of Indigenous participants in the 209 PAFT community dialogues, with more than 1,000 Indigenous women taking part. 

These discussions gave communities a way to decide both how benefits would be distributed and what the funds would support. The UN-REDD Learning Journal on Fair and Equitable Benefit Sharing examines this approach alongside other benefit-sharing arrangements. Completed plans include more than 60 initiatives for women, 50 for young people and 30 for older people. Priorities range from road maintenance and school provisions to productive projects, health, food security and women’s leadership, with resource allocations decided at territorial level. 

Nery Ríos, a technical advisor to the PAFT process in Conte Burica, described what this meant to him. 

“I came to understand that this work is not only about planning, but about listening and giving shape to the dreams and aspirations of my people, envisioning a development path that brings economy and sustainability into balance. It was a challenging process, but also a deeply meaningful learning experience.”
—Nery Ríos

Cultural mediators and the work of building trust 

Putting these plans into practice depended on people who could connect the technical dimensions of REDD+ with communities’ languages, worldviews and experiences. 

The national REDD+ Secretariat formalized a programme of cultural mediators, Indigenous Peoples identified by their own communities for this knowledge. Around 160 mediators were trained during the consultation process. More than 63 were hired during project implementation, and by the end of 2024, 44 percent were Indigenous women. 

The mediators helped communities understand a complex international payment mechanism and brought community perspectives into the process. Their role was especially important where communities had previously seen conservation used against them. 

Representatives from several territories cited mediators as the primary reason their communities were willing to engage. Almost all Indigenous Territories chose to proceed with PAFT development, suggesting that sustained, transparent dialogue helped address early skepticism. 

Giving communities time and a say in the process 

Free, prior and informed consent also depended on how consultation was organized and who shaped it. 

Costa Rica’s 2018 General Consultation Mechanism, Decree 40932, provides for consultation with all governance structures a territory recognizes, through Territorial Indigenous Consultation Bodies. Our project worked through these bodies where they existed and through broader coalitions of representative organizations elsewhere. 

This engagement built on years of consultation and public investment, spanning information sharing, pre-consultation, formal consultation and PAFT development. Community representatives interviewed for the case study credited the 15-year timeframe with giving them space to deliberate without pressure. 

Indigenous Peoples also shaped the methodology. Indigenous leaders developed and proposed the National Indigenous Agreement, signed in December 2012 by representatives of 18 territories and several women’s organizations. The five special themes emerging from consultation reflected community priorities, including an Indigenous-specific PES model, land reclamation and culturally appropriate monitoring. 

From social integrity to carbon market access 

Costa Rica’s experience shows how sustained investment in rights, participation and accountable governance can support credible forest finance. 

Costa Rica became the first country in Latin America and the Caribbean to receive payments from the Forest Carbon Partnership Facility (FCPF) for reducing emissions from deforestation and forest degradation. An initial US$16.4 million payment in August 2022 was followed by $17.5 million, under an Emission Reductions Payment Agreement providing for up to $60 million. 

In June 2026, Costa Rica became the first country to verify national REDD+ removals under TREES, The REDD+ Environmental Excellence Standard of the Architecture for REDD+ Transactions (ART) programme. 

These milestones form part of a wider national effort. Social safeguards provide a basis for assessing whether Indigenous Peoples have been consulted, benefits are shared equitably and governance structures are legitimate. Costa Rica’s consultation process and territorial plans helped put these commitments into practice. 

This combination of national frameworks, territorial governance and community-level consent illustrates the principles at the heart of UNDP’s High-Integrity Carbon Markets Toolkit. The lesson extends beyond any single payment or standard. Credible carbon finance depends on Indigenous Peoples having a meaningful say in the decisions that affect their territories and futures.