Targeted Scenario Analysis
Targeted Scenario Analysis (TSA): A Practical Decision-Makers’ Policy-Centred Economic Analysis Tool to Advance Sustainable Sector Development Policy and Investment
UNDP developed Targeted Scenario Analysis (TSA) to meet the growing demand from decision-makers and stakeholders for effective, policy-relevant economic analysis tools to advance national Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs).
Policy reform is extremely challenging for politicians who manoeuvre within a short-term political planning horizon- the four to five years between election cycles- combined with significant lobbying pressure to maintain the status quo. Meanwhile, natural capital's gradual change provides ample time to follow a "business as usual (BAU)" path of unsustainable, nature-degrading policies over decades. In addition, the lack of economic data showing the economic losses associated with the BAU path from monetary and natural capital perspectives prevents governments from being held accountable for demonstrating sustainable use of and investment in natural capital.
Understanding the reasons underlying policy objectives and shaping economic analysis to address them is critical to improving decision-making and advancing policy reform. Thus, Targeted Scenario Analysis (TSA) offers a practical approach to connecting policy objectives with fit-for-purpose economic analysis. Originally developed in 2013, the TSA Guidebook has been updated based on an extensive review of project portfolios and research supported by leading environmental economists. TSA converts economic data into sustainable sector development policy.
TSA captures and presents the value of ecosystem services to target decision-making, not in a generic, abstract manner. TSA directly compares two policy scenarios. First, a business-as-usual (BAU) scenario in which the status quo conditions, i.e., unsustainable sector management and limited investment, are projected into the future, and second, a so-called sustainable economic management (SEM) scenario. SEM introduces ecosystem and natural capital management improvements into sector development policy and investment.
A vital element of a TSA is that it is conducted for a particular productive sector and tailored to the specific policy objectives of public or private decision-makers in the targeted sector. Agreed-upon policy questions capture these objectives. To define the policy questions more accurately, TSA promotes analysis of policy duplication, fragmentation, overlaps, and gaps.
Policy scenarios are compared using a wide range of carefully selected indicators, in close consultation with the decision-maker (the TSA client). TSA's focus on specific decision-makers (public and private) increases the likelihood that the research data will be used to transition to a more effective and efficient allocation of public and private investment; therefore, it improves the sustainable management of natural capital. By involving multiple decision-makers from the public and private sectors (e.g., high-level public officials, corporate executives, producers, and producers’ associations), the TSA ensures its results can navigate government transitions when an election cycle ends or when public decision-makers turn over quickly.
At the end of a TSA, the evidence generated through research provides balanced insights into the advantages and disadvantages of staying on track with BAU, compared with a change in direction in which the targeted sector manages economic development sustainably and effectively. Another critical element that sets a TSA apart is that it shifts away from generating a policy-isolated single static value toward a long-term analysis. Thus, it shows year-to-year changes between the BAU and SEM scenarios by applying key monetary and non-monetary indicators.
As such, the main product of the TSA is a package of coherent policy recommendations supported by economic evidence for each indicator of the benefits of shifting from BAU to SEM. For each policy recommendation, a subset of indicators and graphs illustrates how these measurable indicators develop over time under both policy scenarios. Each TSA graph includes a narrative that clearly states the primary stakeholder for the analysis, an in-depth description of the methods, assumptions, and data sources used to generate the results, and the associated confidence levels and uncertainty. Beyond explaining the results shown in the graphs, it clearly indicates what those results mean for policy decisions.
TSA provides information on the results of specific decisions and management practices through continuous, long-term analysis, showing relative change over time in key monetary and non-monetary indicators. This approach supports decision-making, as decisions are rarely based on single numbers in isolation, but rather on comparing at least two policy options over time. As the name suggests, Targeted Scenario Analysis has three participatory pillars:
Targeted: TSA helps decision-makers and stakeholders focus on critical decisions, including how the sector manages ecosystem services, leading to improved sustainable economic development outcomes and profitable business. TSA can target management and investment policy, both public and private, at the national and subnational levels.
Scenario: It does this by developing and contrasting existing and future scenarios—Business as Usual vs Sustainable Economic Management—that link changes to biophysical and socio-economic indicators as the scenarios evolve.
Analysis: It presents an in-depth analysis of selected sustainable development indicators over time. Decision-makers select the priority and relevance of these indicators, e.g., changes in soil fertility or water availability; changes in natural capital-based productivity gains and losses; investment costs; avoided costs; net revenues; jobs; and equity- and gender-responsive indicators.
Lessons from implementing TSA have shown that, beyond making a compelling case for shifting from unsustainable to sustainable sector policies and providing policy recommendations, it is indispensable to support the wider policy reform process. Thus, the TSA 2.0 guidebook has been adjusted accordingly; it includes five chapters, of which chapter 1 is updated, and chapters 2, 3, and 5 are new:
- What is TSA, and why is it important?
- Policy, decision-making and policy reform
- PHASE I: Pre-TSA scoping of the enabling policy environment
- PHASE II: Implementing the TSA’s 5-Step Approach
- PHASE III: Follow-up to the TSA’s policy action plan
Watch TSA’s Lead Author, Francisco Alpízar, Professor of Behavioural Economics at the University of Wageningen, and Marlon Flores, Senior UNDP TSA Technical Advisor, talk about the practicality and advantages of TSA:
TSA's value-added
TSA results and the follow-up on the policy action plan can lead to significant benefits at different levels:
Country-level client (government/private sector):
- Improve sector policy design and fiscal reform across sectors.
- Increase the quantity and quality of public and private investment in SDGs.
- Increase sustainable sector productivity and long-term profitability.
- Increase GDP at the sector and national levels.
- Increase direct net benefits for sector producers and value-chain stakeholders.
- Increase other financial, economic, social, and environmental benefits..
Institutional: Successful TSAs increase UNDP and its implementing partners' credibility vis-à-vis government partners, private sector businesses, and producers.
Technical capacity: TSA combines the capacity of UNDP, high-profile companies specialising in TSA valuation, and academia.
Funding donor: Improves donors’ interventions' cost-effectiveness, their support for achieving the SDGs, and new commitments to, for example, tackle climate change preparedness, land restoration, food security, human wellbeing, and ecosystems and biodiversity conservation.
Scalability: High potential for transferring TSA data (results), coherent policy recommendations, and action plans between existing and future TSA studies and implications of achieving policy impact.
Since its initial publication, TSA reports have been generated in over twenty countries, covering renewable, e.g., agriculture (coffee, cocoa, palm oil, sago, crops), livestock, and fisheries, and non-renewable resources, e.g., small-scale mining. TSA also supports protected areas and biodiversity, and nature-based tourism. The TSA's Implementation Map provides an overview of past and present TSA at the global level.
The TSA approach is becoming a key component of UNDP-implemented projects worldwide. UNDP's Food Systems Practice and Ecosystem and Biodiversity Practice have explicitly adopted it as an essential tool to support policy reform on agricultural production and conservation.
TSA's Implementation
Targeted Scenario Analysis Implementation Map
To learn more about TSA country work, click on each country of the list below:
| Report title | Assessment of the contribution of freshwater ecosystem services to the hydropower sector in the Kura-Aras River Basin in Azerbaijan |
| Year of Completition | 2015 |
| Client | Ministry of Energy and Natural Resources, Ministry of Nature Protection and Ministry of Agriculture |
| Authors | Flores, Marlon and Abbasov, Rovshan |
| Funding agency | WWF Caucasus Policy Programme |
| Abstract | Deforestation and unsuitable agricultural practices in the Kura-Aras River Basin in Azerbaijan cause increased erosion and change in water flows, making them an essential threat to the HPP/ dams' development. The study focuses on demonstrating the value of the contribution of biodiversity and ecosystem services to hydropower /dam development by assessing the HPP/dam sector and reviewing different sectors: nature-based tourism, drinkable water supply, irrigated agriculture, and natural hazards. |
| Policy Targets | -Hydropower plants’ regulatory and management framework -Sector investment policy -Environmental impact assessment guideline |
| Download Report |
| Report title | TSA in the Subsistence and Small-Scale Mining Sectors in Colombia |
| Year of Completition | 2022 |
| Client | Ministry of Mines and Energy of Colombia, PlanetGOLD Project |
| Authors | Conservation Strategy Fund (CSF) |
| Funding agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | Subsistence and small-scale gold mining is one of the principal sources of freeing mercury into the environment. This study and the project PlanetGOLD focus on the development of economic models that actualize the mining practices which allow elimination of the liberation of mercury. The analysis considers the following types of mining: subsistence, linked to the use of discarded material from rock and reef mining, small-scale, and associated with alluvial exploitation with a backhoe. |
| Policy Targets | - Action Plan to Strengthen the Responsible Production and Marketing of Pineapple in Costa Rica (Pineapple Action Plan) - Public and corporate mining investment policy |
| Download Report | Coming soon |
| Report title | Sustainable Livestock in the Yarí savannahs, municipalities of Macarena and San Vicente del Caguán, Colombia |
| Year of Completition | 2021 |
| Client | The Ministry of Agriculture and Rural development (MADR) and local governments |
| Authors | Conservation Strategy Fund (CSF) |
| Funding agency | GEF UNDP - PAGE (Partnership for Action on Green Economy) |
| Abstract | Deforestation in the Amazon region presents complex challenges for Colombia. As forest resources are lost, so are the landscape's connectivity, water quality, biodiversity, soil fertility, and greenhouse gas sequestration. This TSA is looking for alternative ways to invest in improving landscape management in the livestock in the San Vicente del Caguán and Macarena municipalities, which leads to profits for the different productive actors in this sector's value chain. |
| Policy Targets | - Conservation agreements policy (under Executive Decree 1076 de 2015) - National PES Program’s guidelines (CONPES 3886 of 2017). - Legal Framework of Autonomous Development Corporations - Revolving fund to support premium prices (Resolution 017 of 2012, Ministry of Agriculture and Rural development (MADR) - Agricultural-Livestock Promotion Fund - Sustainable Agricultural-Livestock and Green Business policy (credit lines) - Establishing a Nacional Livestock Fund under Law 89 of 1993 |
| Download Report |
| Report title | Sustainable water resources management in high migration corridors |
| Year of Completition | Planning stage |
| Authors | TBD |
| Funding Agency | UNDP, TBD |
| Abstract | The Central American Dry Corridor is being affected by the low availability of water resources due to climate change and poor management of water resources. In turn, these factors impact agricultural production and migration. This study aims to assess the economic impact of different approaches to freshwater ecosystem management in the agriculture sector and its links to migration patterns. The study focuses on El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras. |
| Report title | TSA for the Pineapple Sector of Costa Rica |
| Year of Completition | 2016 |
| Client | The Ministry of Agriculture and Livestock of Costa Rica |
| Authors | Francisco Alpízar, Francisco and Salas, Ariana |
| Funding agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The pineapple sector is economically vital for Costa Rica, particularly in the Alajuela, Puntarenas, and Limón regions. Pineapple production is characterized by low environmental and social performance, and to such an extent that it risks the sector's survival. The study analyzes how to improve pineapple production and trade's social and environmental performance to increase its competitiveness and frame this activity within the sustainable development model. |
| Targeted Policies | - The National Pineapple Action Plan - Corporate investment policy |
| Report title | Towards a sustainable agriculture sector in Cuba |
| Year of Completition | Ongoing |
| Client | Ministries of Science Technology and Environment (CITMA) and Agriculture |
| Authors | Enriquez, Celene, et al. |
| Funding agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The TSA evaluates the contribution of ecosystem services (ES) from protected areas, part of the national system of protected areas (SNAP), to vital economic sectors and the national economy. The study will propose sectoral policy reform to increase public and private investment and promote sustainable sectorial economic growth. The study will assess how investing in ecosystems management in sectors that receive ES from PA can reduce threats to conservation and ecosystems, avoid costs and reduce pressures on PAs. Thus, reducing direct protection and conservation costs. The TSA will provide evidence-based data on the value of the financial and economic risks associated with neglecting investment in natural capital. |
| Download Report | Coming soon: - Sector budgeting and investment |
| Report title | Sustainable coffee and cocoa production |
| Year of Completition | 2023 |
| Client | Ministry of Agriculture and Ministry of Environment |
| Authors | The Wolfs Company, part of Grand Thornton |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The study focuses on the impact of coffee and cocoa production on ecosystems to incorporate biodiversity conservation into public policies to face current and future threats to productive mountain landscapes. It will help to ensure the private sector and government commitments to increase the budget and establish financial mechanisms to increase the investment into deforestation-free coffee and cacao and sustainable ecosystem management. |
| Targeted Policies | - The operational framework for sustainable management of productive mountain landscapes - Production systems and conservation of threatened mountain ecosystems and corridors policy - Sustainable livelihoods incorporating friendly agricultural practices with ecosystem services, including biodiversity |
| Download Report |
| Report title | Phasing out mercury in artisanal and small-scale mining |
| Year of Completition | 2021 |
| Client | The Ministry of Energy and Non-renewable Natural Resources |
| Authors | Conservation Strategy Fund (CSF) |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP – PAGE (Partnership for Action on Green Economy) |
| Abstract | In Ecuador, nearly 100,000 people directly depend on Artisanal and Small-Scale Gold Mining (ASGM). Gold is the main export mineral, and ASGM produces at least 85% of Ecuadorian gold, corresponding to more than USD 300,000,000 in annual income. Despite this importance, the sector lacks access to financing, which produces technological inefficiencies, and the persistent pollution from the use of mercury represents a cost of at least USD 80,000,000 per year. The TSA focuses on alternative scenarios that introduce new technologies to reduce the use of mercury, increasing the government gold purchasing policy and private sector investment. |
| Targeted Policies | - Processing plants investment policy - Central Bank purchasing policy Ecuador - Public incentives to regulate the informal sector - Pilot project of the Responsible Beneficiation Program implemented (3 processing plants and 2 analytical laboratories with strengthened capacities). - National Mining Strategy |
| Download Report |
| Report title | Shea forest conservation and sustainable use |
| Year of Completition | Planning Stage |
| Client | Forestry Commission of Ghana (Climate Change Directorate) |
| Authors | TBD |
| Funding Agency | GFC UNDP |
| Abstract | Growing deforestation and removal of trees make agricultural landscapes increasingly prone to desertification, land degradation, and loss of livelihoods, exacerbated by the effects of climate change. The TSA will assess the contribution of restored landscapes and shea forests to the sectorial economic growth. It will assess existing financial and economic losses and the potential gain of increasing investment in shea forest ecosystems restoration, management, and reducing emissions using a range of indicators and subsequently propose the respective policy reforms needed to achieve a more sustainable development path. |
| Targeted Policies | TBD |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
| Report title | Economic Valuation of the Contribution of Ecosystems to Economic Growth and Human Well-Being: The Closter of Protected Areas of Tusheti and the Georgian Network of Protected Areas |
| Year of Completition | 2014 |
| Client | Ministry of Environment and Green Development of Mongolia |
| Authors | Flores, Marlon and Adeishvili, Malkhaz. |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The TSA focuses on the cluster of protected areas of Tusheti Region and provides an overview of the contribution of ecosystem services of Georgia’s Network of Protected areas to growth and human well-being. The study informs policymakers and businesses about the economic risks and opportunities of undertaking productive activities that impact on and are influenced by biodiversity and ecosystem services. Its objective is to ensure the long-term input of ecosystem services, such as tourism, food and water supply, timber, hydropower and fisheries, to secure and increase sector productivity, growth and well-being. |
| Targeted Policies | - Budgetary allocations policy and budget cuts approach - Sector based fiscal reform: freshwater, hydropower and nature-based tourism - Protected areas entry fees policy |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
| Report title | Valuation of ecosystem services of the Chiquimulilla Canal in the artisanal fishing and tourism sectors |
| Year of Completition | 2017 |
| Client | Secretariat for Planning and Programming of the President’s Office (SEGEPLAN) |
| Authors | Enríquez, Celene, et al. |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The Chiquimulilla canal is critical because of its economic value linked to ecosystem services. Despite this value, the canal receives waste discharges. Therefore, it faces high levels of stress that accelerate the deterioration of the quality and quantity of goods and services that the canal produces. The study compares different scenarios for the fishing, shrimp farming, and tourism sectors to present measures to reduce negative externalities in this sensitive ecosystem |
| Targeted Policies | -Municipal budget allocations to ecosystems management (4 municipalities) -Regional Tourism Plan and budget -Municipal solid waste management plans -Municipal freshwater management regulatory framework -Fishing licensing policy -Land use and restoration policy |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
| Report title | Deforestation-free commodities in Indonesia |
| Year of Completition | Planning stage |
| Client | The Coordinating Ministry for Economic Affairs, Ministry of National Development Planning, The Ministry of Agriculture, and District Governments |
| Authors | TBD |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The government of Indonesia will apply five TSA to assess opportunities and the potential economic impact of investing in deforestation-free commodities. To this end, the TSA study will compare different ecosystems management approaches in the targeted commodities to assess potential economic losses or gains resulting from maintaining the business-as-usual production systems or adopting a more sustainable path. The TSA aims to support the transition to sustainable value chains in the palm oil, coffee, cocoa, and rice sectors. The five TSA will target five regions: Aceh, N. Sumatera, W. Kalimantan, W. Papua, and S. Sulawesi. |
| Targeted Policies | - Landscape management policy to integrating biodiversity conservation, ecosystem restoration and the sustainable production of cash and food crops at scale. |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
| Report title | Targeted Scenario Analysis of the Forest Sector in Kazakhstan |
| Year of Completition | 2021 |
| Client | The Ministry of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources |
| Authors | The Wolfs Company, part of Grant Thornton |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The TSA supports the achievement of the Government’s goals to increased forest cover. Thus, the TSA assesses the impact of two forest management scenarios identified in consultation with stakeholders in Kazakhstan. The first scenario assesses current forest management practices and historical trends. The second, looks at the impact of increasing investments to improve forest management and reach the forest cover target of 5% of the surface of Kazakhstan by 2030 |
| Targeted Policies | - Increase in annual budgets for forestry management - Strategic spatial planning for forest conservation, protection and reproduction - Improving forest budget planning and cost-effective use - The 5-year management plan for forest protection institutions - Increase in opportunities for sustainable financing of forest management |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
| Report title | Sustainable alternatives to livestock management in the Inner Tien Shan Mountain range |
| Year of Completition | Ongoing |
| Client | State Agency on Environment Protection and Forestry of the Kyrgyz Republic and Vanishing Treasures Project stakeholders |
| Authors | Gonchigsumlaa, Ganzorig, Flores, Marlon, et al. |
| Funding Agency | UNEP Vanishing Treasures Project |
| Abstract | Mountain communities are heavily dependent on unsustainable livestock practices. Overgrazing and climate change degrade mountain pastures and increase the vulnerability of communities and wildlife to climate change impact. The TSA assesses the financial and economic impact of livestock losses due to degraded pastures, poor field productivity, and predators. The TSA also assesses the shift to sustainable nature-based tourism and other complementary sustainable options, such as beekeeping, to reduce dependency on livestock and explores how improved income could contribute to better conservation, pastures, and wildlife management. The TSA provides data on the cost of shifting from unsustainable to sustainable practices to reduce the impact on mountain pastures and improve local livelihoods. |
| Targeted Policies | TBD |
| Download Report | Policy Brief |
| Report title | High value conservation forest and deforestation-free palm oil |
| Year of Completition | 2020 |
| Client | Inter-Ministerial Commission on Palm Oil Concessions |
| Authors | Conservation Strategy Fund (CSF) |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The Government of Liberia has prioritized the development of palm oil agroforestry concessions, and the interest from global companies confirms palm oil is a significant economic opportunity for the country. Communities and smallholder producers are eager to engage in palm oil concessions because they bring employment and socioeconomic benefits. Nevertheless, the development of the oil palm sector has stalled due to contradicting forest management and concessions policies. The TSA compares economic gains and losses from different possible oil palm development paths in Liberia, including community participation. |
| Targeted Policies | - National interpretation of RSPO principles and management framework - Executive Decree on Government’s position on concessions and concessionaires - Liberia’s National Forest Definition Framework - Smallholder palm oil development policy (credit to finance start-up costs) - Extension services and sourcing inputs policy - Contracting (between the concessionaire and out growers), royalties and benefit sharing policies |
| Download Report |
Report title | An Economic Valuation of the Contribution of Ecosystem Services of the Network of Protected Areas to the Economy of Mongolia |
Year of Completition | 2015 |
Client | Ministry of Environment and Green Development |
Authors | Flores, Marlon, Gonchigsumlaa, Ganzorig and Surenjav, Khorolmaa |
Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
Abstract | The study analyses how a shift from Business-As-Usual PA management to Investing in Natural Capital may result in more sustainable sector productivity and human well-being in Mongolia. The TSA considers the following key sectors: nature-based tourism (NBT), irrigated agriculture, livestock, forests, mining, and drinkable water. |
Targeted Policies | - Protected area’s budget allocations policy: elimination of annual PA budget cuts. |
Download Report |
|
| Report title | Production of Intelligent and Adaptable Livestock in the Paraguayan Chaco |
| Year of Completition | 2021 |
| Client | Ministry of Environment and Sustainable Development, Livestock Cooperatives |
| Authors | Conservation Strategy Fund (CSF) |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The Chaco region supports almost half of Paraguay's livestock sector, and its growth promotes horizontal expansion and land use change to create new productive grasslands. The conversion of forests to pastures has generated conflict between the different actors in the region. The study focuses on the economic reasons and legal reform to improve sustainability, the producers' profitability, and the positioning of Paraguayan meat in regional and global markets for sustainable commodities. |
| Targeted Policies | - Corporate investment in deforestation-free beef policy - Licensing policy for the livestock sector - Institutionalizing sustainable livestock standards and branding (corporate and public regulatory framework) - Public investment in local infrastructure and social services policy |
| Download Report |
| Report title | TSA for the Cacao Value Chain in Peru |
| Year of Completition | 2021 |
| Client | The Ministry of Agriculture and The Ministry of Environment of Peru |
| Authors | Wolfs Company, part of Grant Thornton |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The study compares the financial, economic, and environmental impact of continuing with the current practices in cacao production in the Peruvian Amazon region with adopting alternative practices, which could generate higher profitability and, simultaneously, are more environmentally sustainable. The premise for defining alternative practices is based on meeting demand levels for cacao in 2030 and reducing pressure on forest ecosystems |
| Targeted Policies | - National Plan for Developing the Cocoa-Chocolate Value Chain 2020-2030 - Agricultural finance and credit policy - Land use and landscape management policy - Standards associated with zero-deforestation - Municipal agricultural competitiveness policy - Regulatory framework for cocoa consistency: quality, quality and safety |
| Download Report | Full Report |
| Report title | TSA for the Palm Oil Value Chain in Peru |
| Year of Completition | 2021 |
| Client | The Ministry of Agriculture and The Ministry of Environment of Peru |
| Authors | Wolfs Company, part of Grant Thornton |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The study compares the financial, economic, and environmental impact of continuing with the current practices in palm oil production in the Peruvian Amazon region with adopting alternative practices, which could generate higher profitability and, simultaneously, are more environmentally sustainable. The premise for defining alternative practices is based on meeting demand levels for palm oil in 2030 and reducing pressure on forest ecosystems. |
| Targeted Policies | TBD |
| Download Report | Full Report |
| Report title | An Assessment of the Contribution of Ecosystems in Protected Areas to Sector Growth and Human Well Being in Romania |
| Year of Completition | 2012 |
| Client | The Romanian Forestry Department ROMSILVA |
| Authors | Bogdan Popa, Camille Bann |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The Carpathian Network of Protected Areas (CNPA) has been considered insufficient in scale, connectivity, and management to prevent irreversible biodiversity loss. The territory faces various pressures, including the overexploitation of forest resources, habitat degradation, fragmentation due to poorly planned development, and underfunding. The study aims to generate evidence of how a sustainably managed CNPA supports productivity in critical sectors such as tourism, forestry, and industry and demonstrates costs associated with unsustainable management |
| Targeted Policies | - Protected area’s budget allocations framework - PA entry fees policy - Water-based payments for environmental services framework - Revenue sharing mechanisms |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
| Report title | Sustainable nature-based tourism and climate-smart agriculture in the Virunga landscape |
| Year of Completition | On-going |
| Client | The Great Apes Survival Partnership (UN-GRASP), state governments, the Greater Virunga Transboundary Collaboration Secretariat. |
| Authors | Bush, Glenn, Flores, Marlon et al. |
| Funding Agency | UNEP Vanishing Treasures Projec |
| Abstract | Mountain communities in the Virunga landscape are heavily dependent on crop farming, supplemented by natural resources, for income and food due to increasing food insecurity in the region. Prolonged dry seasons put increased pressure on water resources, negatively affecting small-scale farmers. Additionally, there is increased human-wildlife conflict due to crop raiding by species suffering the consequences of climate change. Thus, if current practices continue, people will increase their dependency on resources from within the national parks. The TSA assesses the economics behind nature-based tourism and climate-smart agriculture options to provide evidence-based data on shifting to sustainable practices to increase livelihood diversity, reduce food insecurity, improve local communities' livelihoods, and reduce the impact on mountain ecosystems. |
| Targeted Policies | TBD |
| Download Report | Policy Brief |
| Report title | Towards a lower impact artisanal and small-scale gold mining |
| Year of Completition | Ongoing |
| Client | The Ministry of Natural Resources of Suriname, Mining Directorate |
| Authors | The Wolfs Company, part of Grant Thornton |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | The TSA supports the uptake of more responsible environmental artisanal small-scale gold mining practices to demonstrate the environmental and economic benefits of environmentally responsible mining practices (ERMPs) and technologies. The proposed model relies on identifying benefits for miners that arise from applying ERMPs, including social and economic benefits, and designing a national-level financial, fiscal, and regulatory incentives system to help re-orient the market towards more responsibly sourced gold. |
| Targeted Policies | TBD |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
| Report title | Combating Illegal Wildlife Trade, with a focus on Ivory, Rhino Horn, Tiger and Pangolin in Thailand |
| Year of Completition | 2021 |
| Client | Department of National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation |
| Authors | International Institute for Environment and Development (IIED) |
| Funding Agency | GEF UNDP |
| Abstract | Wildlife crime drives biodiversity loss and impacts livelihoods, economies, and regional security. Thailand is a source, transit, and destination country for many different types of illegally traded wildlife and wildlife products. This study focused on the social, economic, and environmental losses deriving from the IWT to Thailand and globally and the benefits associated with a reduction/elimination of wildlife trafficking. |
| Targeted Policies | - Annual budget allocations to enforcement agencies to combat IWT and result-based performance indicators. - National wildlife tourism strategy, including reformed protected area entry fees, investment policies, and business planning - Investment to advance investigative techniques, support the DNP's Wildlife Forensic Science (WIFOS) laboratory, and upscale on-the-ground operations - Strengthen Thai WEN, informational management and introduce integrated enforcement networks that include local communities - Private sector investments, and other sources, including international donor transfers. |
| Download Report | Coming Soon |
TSA Success Stories From Around the World
Guatemala - Artisanal fisheries and tourism
In Guatemala, the results of Targeted Scenario Analysis demonstrated that under conditions of “sustainable use” and by the year 2025: capture fisheries benefits increase more than 10-fold; tourism benefits are more than GTQ 200 Million, and aquaculture's per hectare per year income – in contrast to Business as Usual – reaches a massive $40,000 more. The UNDP’s Flor Bolanos says that “The Guatemala case demonstrates how strategic advocacy can positively impact on a number of coastal and marine management initiatives: it has helped fill a critical community fishing data gap; introduced participatory strategies for sustainable use and management; sprung a programme for the prevention, reduction and control of pollution from land-based sources in Marine Protected Areas; among other changes”.
Ecuador – Artisanal and small-scale mining
In Ecuador, nearly 100,000 people directly depend on Artisanal and Small-Scale Gold Mining (ASGM). Gold is the main export mineral, and ASGM produces at least 85% of Ecuadorian gold, which corresponds to more than USD 300,000,000 in annual income. Despite this importance, the sector lacks access to financing, which produces technological inefficiencies, and the persistent pollution from the use of mercury represents a cost of at least USD 80,000,000 per year. Read Ecuador´s Completed TSA and Policy Brief.
Kazakhstan – forestry/forest
To support the achievement of the goals set by the Government of Kazakhstan to increased forest cover, UNDP commissioned Wolfs Company and the VU University Amsterdam to perform a Targeted Scenario Analysis (TSA) for the Ministry of Ecology, Geology and Natural Resources (MEGNR) of the Republic of Kazakhstan.
The TSA assesses the impact of two forest management scenarios that have been identified in consultation with stakeholders in Kazakhstan:
1. The Business-As-Usual scenario (BAU), in which current management practices are continued and historical trends in forest cover continue.
2. The Sustainable Ecosystem Management (SEM) scenario, in which investments are made to improve forest management and reach the forest cover target of 5% of the surface of Kazakhstan by 2030. Read Kazakhstan´s Completed TSA and Policy Brief.
Liberia - High value conservation forest/palm oil
The Government of Liberia has prioritized the development of agroforestry concessions, and interest from global companies confirms palm oil as a significant economic opportunity for the country; they have already invested on the order of US$500 million since 2008. Communities and smallholder producers in and around allocated concessions are eager for concessions to proceed, as employers and purchasers as well as funding sources for socioeconomic benefits such as improved roads and schools. Nevertheless, development of the oil palm sector has stalled.
This study compares economic gains and losses from different possible oil palm development paths in Liberia using Targeted Scenario Analysis (TSA). The UNDP developed the TSA methodology to help decision makers incorporate the value of ecosystem services into public policy. This methodology involves five principal steps. Read Liberia´s Completed TSA and Policy Brief.
Paraguay - Livestock/high value conservation forest
Livestock plays an important role in the Paraguayan economy. In the last 5 years, livestock has contributed almost 10% of GDP, employed around 300,000 people and meat exports have injected an average of 1,100 million dollars annually (MF Economía, 2020). The Chaco region supports 47% of Paraguayan livestock and in turn is an ecosystem of national, regional and global importance due to its biodiversity and natural forests.
However, the growth of the sector is characterized by horizontal expansion and the change of land use to enable new productive plots. In total, it is estimated that only in the western region of the Chaco pastures went from covering six million hectares in 1991 to more than ten million in 2008 (PNC ONU-REDD + Py / SEAM / INFONA / FAPI, 2016). Since then there has been a continuous growth of the sector. To face these challenges, Paraguay has a set of policies and legal instruments related mainly to environmental aspects, such as Forestry Law 422/73 and Law 294/93 on Environmental Impact Assessment, among others. At the same time, many producers state that these laws are rigid and excessively bureaucratic and that they put the economic and environmental sustainability of the sector at risk. Read Paraguay´s Completed TSA and Policy Brief.
Peru – Cacao/palm oil
The Cacao and the Palm Oil TSA study compares the financial, economic and environmental effects of continuing with current practices in cocoa production and oil palm production, versus the adoption of alternative practices, which can generate higher profitability and at the same time are more environmentally sustainable. The main premise for the definition of alternative practices is to satisfy the demand levels projected to 2030 by reducing the pressure on forest ecosystems. To do this, the study analyzes the effects of increasing productive yields with an adjustment in technological management that allows cultivation on degraded lands. Read Peru´s Completed TSA Cacao (EN) (ES), Completed TSA Palm Oil and Policy Brief for both Cacao and Palm Oil.
Colombia – Livestock
Deforestation in the Amazon region presents great challenges for Colombia. As these valuable forest resources are lost, the connectivity of the landscape, the quality of its natural waters, biodiversity, soil fertility, the sequestration of greenhouse gases (GHG) are lost, among many other ecosystem services that characterize the region. Taking into account the regulatory and land use planning frameworks that are being developed for Colombian livestock and the goals and commitments that the country has proposed to reduce its greenhouse gas emissions and conserve protected areas, this study focuses on generating economic information to recommend concrete actions towards a more sustainable livestock in the region that converge with the reduction of deforestation in these valuable ecosystems. Read Colombia’s Completed TSA (ES) and Policy Brief (ES).
Thailand – Illegal Wildlife Trade
Wildlife crime is now considered to be at crisis level - driving biodiversity loss and imposing far-reaching impacts on livelihoods, economies and regional security. It is globally the fourth most lucrative type of transnational crime generating illegal revenue estimated at USD 5 billion to USD 23 billion per annum in 2017. Thailand is a source, transit and destination country for many different types of illegally-traded wildlife and wildlife products. Illegal international trades are mostly of exotic species such as rhino horn, elephant ivory and pangolin. This study aims to improve the decision makers’ awareness of the social, economic and environmental economic losses deriving from the IWT to Thailand and globally and the benefits associated with a reductio/elimination in wildlife trafficking. Read Thailand’s Completed TSA and Policy Brief.
Costa Rica – Sustainable pineapple
UNDP’s Kifa Sasa said that “In Costa Rica, the TSA analyzed the benefits of sustainable pineapple production and led to the development, endorsement and implementation of the Pineapple Action Plan through 4 Ministries. The TSA determined that, over the course of 5 years, implementing the Action Plan would cost approximately US$6.5 million while the increase in benefits could be valued at US$15 million”.
Mongolia – Protected areas and multiple sectors
In Mongolia, Dr. Ganzorig Gonchigsumlaa, co-author of a TSA study on protected areas, states “the TSA demonstrated its value as an effective tool for advocating for both immediate and longer-term changes by the Minister of Environment. The study helped to secure the existing funding for protected areas, based on the valuation of the ecosystem services they provide, and enabled the creation of a fund for the long term”.
For more information on TSA, contact Marlon Flores at marlon.flores@undp.org Global Technical Advisor on Policy and Economic Analysis - TSA, Food Systems.