The Cold War and structural change in global aid networks
November 19, 2026
Introduction
When the Soviet Union collapsed in 1991, the logic that had governed international aid for four decades disappeared almost overnight. For much of the Cold War, aid was shaped less by development need and more by geopolitical alignment, with donors channeling resources toward strategically important allies. This paper asks a simple but important question, focusing on the end of the Cold War: can major geopolitical events produce measurable, structural transformations in how aid flows across the world?
The answer, the data suggest, is yes. And understanding of such transformations is increasingly important as our findings suggest that today's aid system is beginning to show signs of shifting again — this time, more dramatically than at any point since the Cold War's end.
Why this question matters now
The global aid system is under structural pressure. Preliminary OECD data show that official development assistance fell by 23.1 percent in real terms in 2025 — the largest single-year decline ever recorded (OECD, 2025). This followed a 9 percent fall in 2024, meaning the system has shed roughly a third of its post-pandemic peak in just two years. For the first time in decades, France, Germany, the United Kingdom, and the United States simultaneously reduced their ODA contributions. Bilateral aid to the world's least developed countries could fall by as much as a quarter; humanitarian assistance is projected to decline by 21 to 36 percent.
But the current pressure on aid is not only fiscal. It also reflects a broader political shift in how major donors understand the purpose of development assistance. As advanced economies turn inward and increasingly prioritize domestic competitiveness, strategic autonomy, and commercial interests, aid is becoming harder to defend as a primarily humanitarian or developmental commitment. The recent contraction in ODA therefore signals more than budgetary retrenchment. It points to a possible reordering of the principles that have governed the aid system since the postwar period.
This shift is most visible in the United States. In April 2026, the Trump administration instructed U.S. diplomats worldwide to lobby governments to endorse a “Trade Over Aid” declaration at the United Nations — a document that reframes development assistance as a vehicle for commercial gain rather than humanitarian obligation. Secretary of State Marco Rubio’s cable directed embassies to frame the initiative as an opportunity to “promote America First values and create business opportunities for U.S. companies.” Seen alongside the sharp decline in ODA across major donor countries, this initiative suggests that today’s aid system may be facing not just a funding crisis, but a deeper challenge to its underlying rationale.
This is why the end of the Cold War provides such an important historical reference point. The Cold War was arguably the most dramatic geopolitical rupture in the history of modern development assistance, and one of the clearest moments when the global aid landscape may have been reorganized at the system level. By asking whether that rupture produced a measurable structural change — and, if so, in what direction — this study uses the post-Cold War transition as a benchmark for thinking about the present. Understanding how the aid architecture changed after the Cold War therefore allows us to view the current moment not as an isolated disruption, but as part of a longer historical pattern in which major geopolitical shocks redefine the logic, distribution, and structure of development assistance.
How we examined shifts in aid allocation
We constructed the global aid network as a directed graph using bilateral ODA commitment data from the OECD Creditor Reporting System, spanning 1973 to 2024. Each year's data was structured as a network connecting donor to recipient countries, allowing us to track system-level properties over five decades.
The Zivot-Andrews structural break test, a statistical test that identifies discrete shifts in a time series, is applied to indicators including out-degree centralization, network density, and the number of recipient countries (Zivot & Andrews, 1992; Kiyota; 2023; Freeman, 1979; Butts, 2006). In this directed network, a donor’s out-degree is the number of recipient countries to which it provides aid in a given year. Out-degree centralization, following Freeman (1979), summarizes how unevenly these outgoing ties are distributed across donors in the network: higher values indicate that aid relationships are dominated by a smaller number of highly connected donors. By contrast, the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index (HHI) is a donor-level measure of how concentrated each donor’s bilateral ODA commitments are across recipients.
What the data shows
The Zivot-Andrews test identifies a statistically significant structural break at the 1% level around 1993 in two key indicators: out-degree centralization and the number of recipient countries. Both are consistent with the geopolitical consequences of the Soviet collapse: a sudden expansion of the recipient pool and a rapid unwinding of Cold War-era aid allocation based on strategic interests (Meernik et al., 1998; Bermeo, 2017;).
Two changes drive this result. First, the number of recipient countries increased rapidly as transition economies in Eastern Europe and Central Asia entered the aid system following the Soviet collapse (IMF, 2000; White, 2002). Second, out-degree centralization peaked at the same time and then began a sustained decline. In other words, the number of aid relationships became less concentrated among a small group of highly connected donors. This reflects the unwinding of Cold War-era aid relationships and a move toward broader, more diversified allocation patterns (Steinward, 2015; Peterson, 2014).
Over the next two decades, traditional Western donors converged toward a common model of giving: distributing relatively small amounts of aid across a large number of recipient countries. This "broad and shallow" approach became the dominant pattern in the post-Cold War era. However, that pattern is no longer stable. Since around 2020, the data show increasing divergence across donors. Some are reducing the number of recipients and becoming more selective. Others are concentrating large volumes of aid on specific countries, most notably Ukraine.
At the same time, emerging non-DAC donors are operating with allocation patterns that differ substantially from those of traditional Western donors. Instead of the broad-and-shallow model that became common among DAC donors, Middle Eastern donors tend to allocate aid more selectively: Saudi Arabia and the United Arab Emirates concentrate aid among a smaller set of Middle Eastern, North African, and South Asian recipients, while Turkey’s portfolio was even more concentrated: from 2018 to 2024, Syria consistently accounted for more than 93 percent of its bilateral ODA commitments.
Implications for development practitioners
The most actionable finding from this research comes from the supplementary donor-level HHI analysis: not all donors are equally relevant for all recipients, and misreading that alignment can waste limited engagement time. The data reveal clear structural patterns in which each donor concentrates its aid, patterns shaped by historical ties that often prove remarkably durable. Japan’s aid portfolio, for example, has remained strongly anchored in Southeast Asia and South Asia, with India, the Philippines, and Indonesia consistently among its major recipients. France has maintained deep commitments across Francophone Africa, including Morocco, Côte d'Ivoire, Cameroon, Tunisia, and Senegal. Germany operates one of the broadest and most diversified portfolios among major donors, making it comparatively receptive to engagement across both Africa and Asia. The United Kingdom’s portfolio, meanwhile, has steadily reoriented toward Sub-Saharan Africa since the 1990s, where Commonwealth ties continue to shape allocation patterns.
The current geopolitical environment has complicated this picture. Our analysis of OECD CRS commitment data shows a sharp reorientation beginning in 2022. By 2024, Ukraine accounted for 65.4 percent of Canada’s bilateral ODA commitments and 25.7 percent of those of the United States. Both donors are consequently less available for non-priority recipients than at any point in recent memory. France and Japan, by contrast, barely shifted their portfolios, reflecting how deeply embedded some historical commitments are. For practitioners navigating today’s constrained environment, this means that donor engagement should be based not only on current funding volumes, but also on the structural stability of each donor’s portfolio and its susceptibility to geopolitical redirection.
The deeper lesson is that aid portfolios are neither fully fixed nor easily redirected. They are shaped by colonial histories, linguistic ties, regional affinities, and security relationships, but they can also reorganize quickly when geopolitical shocks alter donor priorities. This makes donor-specific engagement more important than ever. In a period of shrinking aid budgets and rising geopolitical turbulence, practitioners need more tailored engagement strategies: identifying where historical affinities remain strong, where donor attention has been redirected, and where diversified partnerships are most urgently needed. Reading the structural logic of donor portfolios is therefore not a purely academic exercise; it is a practical tool for navigating an aid landscape that is becoming more selective, more heterogeneous, and more politically contingent.
This blog post draws on the research project "The Cold War and Structural Change in Global Aid Networks" authored by research resident Hyeonsong Kim under the KU Development Futures Lab Student Research Residency Programme, supported by the UNDP Seoul Policy Centre.
This article represents the views of the author and does not reflect the views of UNDP.
Hyeonsong Kim is an M.A. candidate in the Department of Business Administration at Korea University, studying international trade and finance, with a particular interest in how geoeconomic fragmentation is evolving and reshaping cross-border trade and financial flows (Email: kimhyeons@korea.ac.kr)
About the United Nations Development Programme
UNDP is the leading United Nations organization fighting to end the injustice of poverty, inequality, and climate change. Working with our broad network of experts and partners in 170 countries, we help nations to build integrated, lasting solutions for people and planet. Learn more at undp.org or follow at @UNDP.
About UNDP Seoul Policy Centre
UNDP Seoul Policy Centre is a facilitator of innovative development cooperation to catalyse the achievement of the Sustainable Development Goals. Through its SDG Partnerships programme and other South-South and Triangular Cooperation initiatives, the Centre supports countries by sharing innovative, tested-and-proven practices and policy tools on strategic development issues globally. Learn more at undp.org/policy-centre/seoul or follow at @UNDPSPC.
References
- Bermeo, S. B. (2017). Aid allocation and targeted development in an increasingly connected world. International Organization, 71(4), 735–766.
- Butts, C. T. (2006). Exact bounds for degree centralization. Social Networks, 28(4), 283-296.
- Freeman, L. C. (1979). Centrality in social networks conceptual clarification. Social networks, 1(3), 215-239.
- Kiyota, K. (2023). The COVID-19 pandemic and the world machinery trade network. ERIA Discussion Paper Series, No. 482.
- International Monetary Fund. (2000). Transition: Experience and policy issues. In World Economic Outlook (October 2000).
- Meernik, J., Krueger, E. L., & Poe, S. C. (1998). Testing models of US foreign policy: Foreign aid during and after the Cold War. The journal of Politics, 60(1), 63-85.
- OECD. (2025). Development aid at a critical juncture: 2025 DAC Global Outlook on Financing for Sustainable Development. OECD Publishing.
- Peterson, L. (2014). A gift you can’t refuse? Foreign aid, INGOs and development in the world polity. Studies in Emergent Order, 7(2014), 81-102.
- Steinwand, M. C. (2015). Compete or coordinate? Aid fragmentation and lead donorship. International Organization, 69(2), 443–472.
- White, H. (2002). Long-run trends and recent developments in official assistance from donor countries. WIDER Discussion Paper.
- Zivot, E., & Andrews, D. W. K. (1992). Further evidence on the great crash, the oil-price shock, and the unitroot hypothesis. Journal of Business & Economic Statistics, 10(3), 251–270.