Issues Paper No. 9
"A TORA MOUSSO KELE LA": A CALL
BEYOND DUTY
OFTEN OMITTED ROOT CAUSES OF MATERNAL MORTALITY IN WEST
AFRICA
Alpha Boubacar Diallo
Endnotes
Acknowledgements
Biographical Note
It is one of the merits of
the Nairobi (1987) and Niamey (1989) conferences on Safe
Motherhood to have brought to the attention of the
international community the true dimension and nature of
the long neglected and tragic problem of maternal
mortality. Their call for action has produced an
encouraging mobilization of international and national
institutions and organization, with new studies of the
problem being undertaken and new national programmes
being developed.
While there is a consensus
that the most appropriate approach to solving the problem
of maternal mortality has to be multisectoral and
multidisciplinary, most of the strategies developed so
far have put the major emphasis on a medical solution,
with sometimes limited socio-economic supporting
interventions. By contrast, the socio-cultural dimension
has so far received very little attention in both referenced
studies and in the development of national programmes. In
most cases, socio-cultural conditions have been lumped in
with the socio-economic factors.
One of the reasons
for this situation could be the bias of research towards
quantitative methodologies. Another reason is the
understandable caution required in handling cultural
values, together with a judgment that these are difficult
to change.
Is the omission of
the socio-cultural dimension justified for any
understanding of such a sensitive, intimate, complex but
also important phenomenon as is human reproduction? In
doing so, are we running the risk of overlooking some key
primary causes in the pursuit of symptoms and secondary
causes? This has serious implications for the
effectiveness of strategies designed to bring about the
conditions essential and necessary for assuring safer
motherhood for millions of women, particularly in the
developing world.
It was during a 6000
km journey through rural Senegal in 1989 to collect data
for a study on maternal mortality that the importance of
the socio-cultural dimension was clearly illustrated. We
were privileged to a wide spectrum of rich experiences.
Some were unusual, many were dramatic and most were
deeply moving. From this mass of data, impressions and
feelings, two critical impressions stand out.
First, a strong
connection was established with the women we met. The
success of our approach was thus predicated on an ability
to explain the purpose of the study (1), and consequently to gain the active
support of the host community through an equal
partnership. One outcome was our strong sense of moral
obligation to improve the fate of these women, and to
help them avoid the tragedy of maternal mortality, a risk
they face during each and every pregnancy.
The second observation is
that, while the team felt that the findings of the study
had made some significant contribution to the
understanding of factors affecting maternal mortality
through a systematic investigation of factors
contributing to maternal death in both the health system
and the community; including the modelling of demand and
supply for obstetric services; the development of an
index of obstetric risks; the correlation between risk
and knowledge; the distance from a health centre, etc.,
our Report could only capture a small fraction of the
reality that we had experienced.
Beneath the reality
open to study with the tools and methodologies generally
used to analyze the phenomenon of maternal mortality lie
other crucial determinants. Understanding these could be
essential if one is ever to develop effective strategies
which reduce rates of maternal mortality in West Africa.
Let us explore the
nature and consequences of these determinants and their
implications for the development of effective strategies
for substantially reducing maternal mortality.
These determinants
are best summarized by the expression: "a tora
mousso kele la", which in Bambara is an
expression used for the loss of life of a woman in
childbirth. The equivalent is: "she fell on the
battlefield in the line of duty".
The internal logic
and corresponding concepts embodied in this expression
are an integral part of a larger reality, namely a system
of societal beliefs developed through the ages to manage
a major event: the procreation process. As with any such
system, society also develops a related set of practices,
customs, and normatively sanctioned behaviours within its
accepted values which become elements of its culture.
From the onset and
throughout the field trip we were to discover the
importance of the socio-cultural dimension.
The initial indication
came from our first community interview. To compensate
for the small size of our sample and improve the
reliability of our results, we chose to collect the data
from three independent sources. For data on maternal
deaths we used the local government official census
documents, the health services statistics, and the
community official records, and then carried out our
in-depth interview of community leaders. We then checked
for inconsistencies and discrepancies.
We soon discovered
that for the collective memory of the community (2) that maternal death was a
"non event". We could not get data from a
direct question such as, How many maternal deaths
occurred during a given time period? We had to devise a
four-step approach. We started with the total number of
deaths for the period. From this total we got the number
of deaths to women. Then from the latter the number of
deaths within the age bracket 15 to 45. Finally we
correlated this number to known pregnancies and births.
Many significant
determinants of maternal mortality can be attributed to a
large extent to the "logical" implications of
the Bambara expression.
Let us examine some
of these implications and their consequences for maternal
mortality. Finally we can see how these elements will
affect the choices for an effective set of strategies for
the development of programmes for safer motherhood.
The implicit
assumptions underlying the expression are:
1) Childbirth is
assimilated to a battle.
2) Any battle, in essence,
has inherent and unavoidable associated risks. Among the
risks are casualties and deaths.
3) It is the duty, not to
say destiny, of women to have to go through this battle
in order to achieve the ideal family size required by the
norms of society.
4) As a
"warrior", the pregnant woman is valued for her
bravery, expressed in terms of stoicism.
5) In preparation for the
battle, the major emphasis is centered around
psychological coping strategies for achieving the stoic
stance.
6) Society, for its part,
develops strategies to transcend the adversity of an
eventual casualty; in this instance, maternal death.
7) The phenomena of both
is beyond our power to understand: being supernatural.
8) It is also beyond our
abilities to defend ourselves against this phenomenon
through ordinary measures.
9) Thus traditional
interventions will be on the plane of metaphysics.
In most of West Africa
many key issues related to the ways devised by society to
manage the phenomenon of reproduction have serious impact
on a number of determinants of maternal mortality. A
fuller understanding of the problem would thus require
consideration of the socio-cultural context. From this
perspective, a key cultural parameter is the importance
given to the continuation of lineage. It is deeply rooted
in the world view of the society and shapes its value
system.
Using a battle as
a metaphor for childbirth emphasizes the recognition by
society of the high level of risk associated with giving
birth. The women are called upon to fight this risky
battle as a matter of DUTY. The fate of women is thus
subordinated to the realization of the requirements for
the continuation of the lineage.
The first
requirement for the continuation of the lineage is the
value placed on childbearing. In the scale of social
values childbearing is elevated to a virtue which confers
high social status. On the other hand, a stigma is
attached to a childless woman who is often regarded as
tainted with sin and, at worst, with evil. In parts of
West Africa, where funeral rites play an important
function in social relations, the ultimate punishment is
reserved for barren women and for those losing their life
in childbirth. They are denied normal funeral rites and
are buried secretly at night outside the village. It is a
case of the society reserving its harshest punishment for
its innocent victim.
By focussing on
fertility to satisfy the continuity of the lineage, women
are under strong pressures to bear children. Most studies
have shown that it is only after 6 to 8 surviving
offspring that a substantial majority of African women
wish to stop childbearing. But under prevailing
conditions of high infant mortality, to insure the
probability of survival of the desired optimum family
size condemns women to repeated and frequent pregnancies.
In part, this may explain the high fertility rates still
observed in most of Africa and the associated high
maternal mortality.
I was recently
alerted to the strength of the value attached to
childbearing even in a non-traditional urban environment.
A well-traveled and western educated professor of social
sciences at an institution of higher learning, out of
sympathy for the "desperate" situation of her
sister who has been unable to bear children, decided to
get pregnant for her sister. This is viewed as a proof of
deep love. Her sister will raise the child as her own.
The consequences of
numerous and frequent pregnancies in order to attain a
socially determined ideal family size expose African
women to a higher lifetime risk of maternal death (1 in
21) compared with women in northern Europe (1 in 9.850).
The responsibility
for the fulfillment of the requirements for the
continuation of the lineage is vested in the clan. This
exclusive social organization is characterized by a
strong interrelationship of mutual support and
obligations binding the members together. It is governed
by the principle of subordination of individual interests
to those of the group. The notion of duty is toward the
group: the extended family. The role of women in the
reproduction process is subordinated to the requirement
of maintaining the "viability" of the extended
family. She is a passive actor called upon to fulfill
with "dignity" and "modesty" her
ascribed duties.
I have often been
baffled by the extravagance of naming ceremonies in West
Africa. Even in periods of deep economic crisis, these
are grandiose festive events requiring lavish expenditure
way beyond what the majority of the population could
afford. In this always well-attended event, the mother of
the newborn is conspicuously anonymous in the group of
women. What is being celebrated is not even the newborn
but first and foremost the lineage and, secondly, its
strengthening through the name given. This is amplified
by the "griot" (3) in his litany on the pedigree of the
extended family. This glorification calls for lavish
rewards to the benefit of the griots.
While preparing this
paper, I had a discussion with a medical doctor friend.
She related a recent incident and how hurt and angry it
made her. While recuperating from a cesarian section in a
private clinic, the aunts of her new-born burst into her
room. She was barely greeted and all the attention was
focussed on the baby. They had come to take the baby for
the naming ceremony. She was left by herself to endure
both physical and emotional pain. "She was only
doing her duty"!
One consequence of
this subordination of the individual to the "greater
good" of the group, the extended family, is that the
major decisions during the reproduction process which
affect the whole life of women are outside their control.
Society is depriving them of the authority for autonomous
decision making in this vital event in their lives. They
are powerless in making the decisions that shape
their fate. During our field trip we came across over and
over again cases requiring an urgent medical evacuation
to a nearby health center being unduly delayed or not
acted upon because the husband, whose consent for such a
decision was required, was either working in the field or
absent.
While this could be
expected in a traditional social setting, women do not
fare better in the modern health delivery system. Here
they are subjected to mutually reinforcing sets of
unfavorable circumstances. While the health providers
have acquired the medical skills based on scientific
knowledge, their behaviour is shaped by the prevailing
traditional social values that they have retained. They
operate in a health structure model inherited from the
former colonial power in which the decision making
process is the exclusive, unchallenged privilege and
prerogative of health providers. It should be remembered
that the bulk of expatriate medical personnel was then
made up of military health providers. Finally the maze of
bureaucratic hurdles with unpredictable rules changing
according to the mood, personality or personal interest
of each agent can severely limit the access of health
services in emergencies for those without connections or
wealth.
It has been
estimated in a major urban center that in the great
majority of the SMI (MCH centers) it took only six
minutes for most of the midwives to conduct a normal
prenatal consultation with a predominance of one-way
communication (4).
It is also not uncommon to see visiting teams being taken
through the delivery room while a woman is in labor
without ever seeking her prior permission or consent.
The study project
offices were located in a major urban SMI. I once
witnessed the heroic efforts of a caring resident doctor
to secure admission for an emergency case patient into
the hospital. The patient had been shuttling back and
forth between health facilities. Finally, as a last
resort, the supervisor advised the doctor to deposit the
patient at the entrance of the hospital and hope for a
miracle, so that she could at least attend to her heavy
case load at the SMI.
In order to fulfill
their ascribed "duty" to the extended family,
the whole life cycle of women is affected. From childhood
she will be prepared to play her roles of wife and
mother. At a very tender age she will be initiated to
demanding domestic work while her brothers are spending
most of their time playing children's games. In any
compound it is common to see little girls helping their
mothers while the little boys are roaming free of
responsibilities. In most cases she will be eating with
the women. A well-bred wife is expected to reserve the
best portions for her husband. The little girl will share
the meals with the women and most probably receive less
in terms of nutrition than her brothers. Because her
destiny is first and foremost to be a good wife and
mother, she will have less chance for formal education or
training than boys. In our study, only 7% of the women
could read. Because of the very strong social stigma
attached to the status of unmarried women, the family is
under strong pressure to marry her to the first
convenient party. In most cases, this will be at an age
when her body is not yet ready for childbearing. In our
study, 7 women out of 10 had their first birth before
they reached 17 years. Because of the dishonor on the
family name attached to pregnancies outside marriage,
unwanted pregnancies are kept secret and preferably
terminated through clandestine abortion under less than
optimal sanitary conditions -- a major cause of maternal
deaths.
The preparation of young
women for safe motherhood is totally inadequate. In terms
of acquisition of a useful knowledge base, this is most
often limited to reassurances about the menstrual process
along with advice on personal hygiene. Pregnancy,
delivery and care of the newborn is seldom explored in
detail. If it is, it will be in the form of metaphors
requiring guesses at the true meaning. Further, the code
of behaviour set up by society does not allow for frank
discussion between a mother and daughter on reproductive
matters. Even if this was possible, its usefulness would
be limited because the society does not seem to have
accumulated a practical knowledge base to systematically
pass on from one generation to the next. The information
transmitted takes the form of "stories" among
peers or parables from the older generation which are
very difficult to decipher for a young woman with little
life experience.
In our study we
attempted to determine the knowledge base of our target
population on indications of a normal pregnancy,
complications during pregnancy and delivery. On the scale
of the knowledge index we developed, 58% scored low, 36%
average and only 7% high. We did find a correlation
between a higher score and having experienced the event
themselves and also being at a greater distance from a
health center. When presented with facts indicating a
probability of a severe hemorrhage some of the women we
interviewed indicated that they believed this to be a
good sign because the body was eliminating the bad blood
to be replaced by new blood.
Contrary to the
inadequacy of preparing young women for safer motherhood
in terms of useful factual information, the psychological
preparation receives a major emphasis. The desired
outcome is to increase the threshold of tolerance to
physical pain. This is to be demonstrated through stoic
behaviour. A common example is the advice given to young
women to be prepared to endure a level of effort equal to
that which would be required to produce water by pressing
hard enough on a stone. The pains of delivery are endured
in expectation of harder moments to come. One is
surprised and relieved after delivery not to have gone
through the dreaded anticipated level of pain. The
desirable heroic stance is usually rewarded by lavish
praise for the demonstrated courage and admiring
compliments from the women attending the new mother and
also from the family members and the community. A less
than "heroic" behaviour is the subject of
verbal abuse and scorn. At this point a paradox is worth
exploring. The midwives in maternity wards are notorious
for their ill treatment of their patients. One would have
expected a more supportive behaviour because of their
training, the ethics of the medical profession and the
fact that they also are mothers. On close examination one
can see that their behaviour is quite similar to that of
the traditional birth attendants when confronted with
similar situations. Their behaviour is culturally
determined and is guided by the norms requiring the
mother to maintain a stoic stance. Because of this
stoicism, vital life threatening signals that require
urgent and immediate action are suppressed and not
communicated until too late, leading to tragic loss of
life.
In place of a body
of practical knowledge capable of insuring safer
motherhood, traditional society has developed a
supernatural set of explanations for the phenomenon of
reproduction. This has led to the attitude that the
phenomenon is beyond the power of rational understanding.
This being so, there are no concrete steps that can be
taken to modify a predetermined outcome. the
interventions to secure a favorable outcome will be in
the realm of metaphysics and call for traditional
para-psychological therapy.
The consequence of these
attitudes is a large number of non-assisted births. Our
findings indicate that only 2 out of 5 women received
assistance from a qualified birth attendant during
delivery. It is worth noting that traditional birth
attendants usually intervene only during the last phase
of delivery -- the expulsion. Further if they intervene
in case of complications, they are more likely to
increase the risk to the life of the mother and baby by
ill-timed, unsafe and intrusive interventions to speed up
the process.
Society has
developed coping strategies of "denial"
for dealing with maternal mortality which is treated as a
"non-event" in the collective memory of the
community. This attitude of "denial" is
also found among health providers at all levels of the
health services. As pointed out by Pr Fadel Diadhiou of
the Dantec Teaching Hospital, maternal death is too often
viewed as "daily occurrence dramatically
common" (5).
He has been working with great dedication to bring about
a change in this prevailing attitude. He keeps
emphasizing to his students and staff that each maternal
death should be regarded as a dramatic event which should
mobilize the conscience of each health provider so as to
make it an event as rare as possible.
Those who are
advocating caution on the ground of sensitivity or
respect for the integrity of the host culture have to
weigh this against the fact that any delay in ACTING NOW
is to condone the avoidable cruel and unjust death of
millions of innocent women (one death every minute).
A closer examination will
show that methodological considerations are not a real
obstacle to the inclusion of socio-cultural variable in
our study of maternal mortality.
These quantitative
methodologies do not necessarily always lead to effective
policies and programmes, and qualitative methods can
yield valuable results in terms of effective strategies.
While quantitative methods demonstrate possible
relationships between dependent and independent
variables, as well as the strength or significance of the
relationship, qualitative methods allow a more general
understanding of the phenomena under investigation by
analyzing it within the sub-system of which it
constitutes an element. This requires first an
understanding of the internal logic of the sub-system
along with its relation to the larger system. Only then
can the logical sequencing of the chain of causality be
established. From this chain the key variables can be
identified along with their relative significance in
explaining phenomena. In our case study, we focussed on
the dominance of the centrality of the continuity of the
lineage in the socio-cultural value system as a key
element in understanding maternal mortality.
The results of our
analysis of the system can be used for programme
development. Identification of key parameters permits the
design of effective strategies so as to affect events
along the chain of causality in order to achieve desired
outcomes. Programme effectiveness will be enhanced by
testing the consistency of a selected strategy with the
internal logic of the system.
For example, in the
case of socio-cultural values affecting some important
determinants of maternal mortality in West Africa, we can
for the purpose of programme design consider two enabling
factors. These are the moral duties of children toward
their mother, and the web of mutual obligations required
from the members of the extended family.
While society in
West Africa confers status to women bearing children,
this translates into worship of mothers by their
children. As a rule of thumb, insulting a peer could lead
to a quarrel; if it is someone's father, this could
escalate to a serious conflict. Insulting someone's
mother, he will have to fight if he is a man of honour,
even if he is sure of loosing the battle. The implied
moral foundation of mother worship is the debt of
gratitude owed to the one who has given us the gift of
life. Mother worship is an important element of the
values system. Since society requires a fight to preserve
the honor of one's mother, to be consistent it cannot
require less to preserve her life particularly when she
is giving the gift of life. Therefore, society will have
to promote safer motherhood. This, in turn, implies the
need to remove the "denial" surrounding
the tragedy of maternal mortality. This will necessitate
that society finally come to terms with this tragedy and
give it the too long overdue priority it deserves. Only
then can we have genuine community mobilization of
conscience, will and resources to address the problem.
This would be a
major area of strategy design for programme development.
Some immediate outcomes of this social mobilization would
be a substantial reduction in the workload presently
required from pregnant women, the removal of food taboos
for better nutrition and reallocation of financial
resources from name giving ceremonies to pre-natal and
natal care. An example is the practice on the island of
Gorée for friends and family to contribute for every
pregnant woman toward acquiring a layette. The island is
linked with the mainland by a ferry boat only during the
day. The maternity is lacking the bare essentials, as is
often the case. The layette is meant to solve these
problems; it will usually have the minimum required
supplies for safe delivery and post natal care for the
newborn. As far as accessibility is concerned, the great
majority of the rural population in West Africa lives on
"islands".
The web of mutual
obligations characteristic of extended family translates
in the area of health into a system of continuous support
through physical presence of relatives and friends. In
sharp contrast to the western need for privacy in such
circumstances, in West Africa this would be perceived as
a form of punishment through isolation and exclusion from
the group. With some exceptions, the layout of health
services has not yet come to terms with the reality that
the family will move in with the patient.
Curiously, a notable
exception to providing this network of support through
physical presence is with birthing. Tragically it is when
the woman is most in need of physical, material and
emotional support that she is left by herself to cope
with the challenges of childbearing. This is even more
tragic with the case of a large number of inexperienced
young women with their first child.
A second major area of
strategy design for programme development could be the
extension of this support system to childbearing. Again,
society, to be consistent with the value accorded to
childbearing cannot deny the necessary support required
to achieve the desired outcome. To this end, two basic
premises in the belief system which hold that the
phenomenon of childbearing is beyond our understanding
and, secondly, that it is beyond our power to modify the
course of events, have to be shown to be no longer valid.
The realization by society of the possibilities for
ACTION which would enhance favorable outcomes will give
the necessary purpose to extending the support system to
childbearing and safer motherhood.
This new knowledge
and understanding of the attitudes of the community could
impact now on several determinants of maternal mortality.
Thus, identifying the web of the family support system
could promote a more systematic follow-up of each
pregnancy and an earlier identification of problems. It
provides a mechanism for more rapid decision making in
case of emergencies, even in the absence of the husband.
Most importantly, it could drastically reduce the number
of unattended deliveries. Finally, the positive
psychological impact on pregnant women cannot be
underestimated.
A major element for
the success of the extended support system would be the
role to be played by traditional birth attendants since
they are already an integral part of the community. The
experience of Professor Fall in Khombole, Senegal has
shown that trained and supervised birth attendants over a
period of years have achieved significantly better
results in reducing maternal mortality than midwives in
the formal health service. This opens up the possibility
of solving the problems resulting from unattended
deliveries in a very short time period. The role of
traditional birth attendants in this strategy should not
be one of an inexpensive substitute for para-medical
personnel but should be that of an active agent of social
change within their community.
One important result
of the Nairobi and Niamey conferences is the Safe
Motherhood Initiative. Since then, there has been an
increase in interest for the problem of maternal
mortality. More research has been undertaken. Some
countries have initiated programme development
activities. A broad approach was recommended in
recognition of the fact that a combination of factors:
medical, socio-economic and cultural, affect maternal
mortality.
So far, most of the
studies and corresponding programmes have put most of the
emphasis on strategies based on medical solutions. This
bias can partly be explained by the choice of variables.
These studies are centered around intermediate and
proximate factors affecting maternal mortality but
underlying factors such as socio-cultural parameters have
been notably neglected. This approach has serious
shortcomings and inevitably limits the effectiveness of
the corresponding public policy strategies. Analyzing
only some elements of a phenomenon in isolation can lead
to erroneous conclusions when used as a basis for
decisions affecting the whole system.
An illustration is
the study by Harrison in Northern Nigeria (6) on the effect of the health care
and intensive nutrition programme for pregnant women in
relation to operative delivery due to fetopelvic
disproportion. He concluded that, for a generation or
more, for small women (150cm or less) there will be a
rise of the operative delivery rate for fetopelvic
disproportion due to gain in weight of the foetus. The
absence of a programme to treat the increase in obstetric
complications could lead to an increase in maternal
mortality.
For programme
development does this mean that health care and intensive
nutrition only benefit the foetus? Unless there are
adequate health services capable of treating the
obstetric complications, should the nutrition programme
be abandoned for small women?
Another shortcoming
of an exclusively medical solution is an implicit
assumption that an effective demand exists and that the
problem is primarily from the supply side. This is often
not verified by the field realities. In our study, the
analysis of demand and supply for obstetric services gave
the following results: 83% felt the need for the
services, 79% wanted them but only 39% actually sought
the services.
We visited 43 health
facilities, including a newly built regional hospital.
None could compare in cleanliness and comfort for the
patient to a community built health post run by a dynamic
group of women's organizations but we were surprised to
find out that it was seldom used. The reason was that the
door was in full view of a regular meeting place for men.
This lack of privacy discouraged many women from using
the facility. After a meeting of community leaders, it
was decided to move the meeting place.
This is not to imply
that the medical solution is not essential to the
solution of the problem of maternal mortality. It is a
necessary but not sufficient condition. Medical and
non-medical solutions are not mutually exclusive; in
fact, they are complementary and allow synergy among
activities. Without strategies dealing with the
socio-cultural constraints and involving the active
partnership of the community, health services even if
they are appropriate and adequate, which is often not the
case, will continue to be overwhelmed by the scope and
complexities of the problem. For any programme to be
effective, there is need for an optimum mix of strategies
taking into consideration all the major factors in the
chain of causal events that affect maternal mortality.
In the West African
context, the problem of maternal mortality is deeply
rooted in the socio-cultural value system of society.
Since along the path all the factors that contribute to
maternal health are interrelated, a viable programme has
to take these into consideration for strategies to be
effective. It is therefore essential not to omit the root
causes. As one moves down the path, opportunities for
effective interventions are missed while the
probabilities of unfavorable outcomes increase.
Unfortunately, this is too often the case with a great
number of women reaching the health facilities too late
to be saved, as is shown by higher maternal mortality
ratios from most hospital service statistics.
"A tora
mousso kele la"! If society is going to send the
women to battle, then it must remove the mines from the
battlefield. The necessary knowledge about the nature of
the mines, their location and how to remove them is now
available. It must also provide full support: material,
physical and emotional. Finally, it should honor those
who have been willing to give the precious gift of life
sometimes at the risk of their own. It is a moral
obligation for society to minimize casualties on the
"battlefield" of motherhood. One fundamental
human right is the right to life. Safe motherhood is a
fundamental human right. There is no democracy without
fundamental human rights being respected. The new hope
for democratization in Africa will never be fulfilled as
long as half of the population is denied a fundamental
right: safe motherhood.
AND THE TIME
FOR ACTION IS NOW!
Endnotes
1. DIA,
A., et al, "Rapport de la Deuxieme Mission
D'Identification Pour la Reduction de la Mortalite
Maternelle au Senegal".
2. The collective memory of the
community is significant, particularly in societies with
oral traditions. It constitutes a driving force of most
social events.
3. Griot: Caste of traditional
musician-entertainers of West Africa. They have an
uncommon mastery of the spoken word. They are the
depository of the history and traditions of the clan as
well as the genealogies of important extended families.
4.
Aissatou Lo, "Impact of Surveillance of High Risk
Pregnant Women in Urban Areas".
5. Dia,
A. et al. Op. Cit.
6. Harrison, K.A. "Predicting
Trends in Operative Delivery for Cephalopelvic
Disproportion in Africa". Lancet, April 7, 1990.
Acknowledgements
This paper was
prepared for The Center For Population and Family Health,
Columbia University for Safer Motherhood, 1991. I would
like to express my sincere gratitude to the mission team:
Medecin Colonel Amadou Dia, Dr. Abdoulaye Gueye, Mme
Khady Ndiaye Fall, Mlle Salimata Ba and Dr. Patrick
Kelly; also to Ms. Mina Mauerstein-Bail.
My most profound gratitude
to the women we met and, through them, the African women:
our daughters, wives and mothers, for their modesty,
courage and caring. They generously give the best of
themselves to sustain the viability of our family,
community and society while receiving so little!
Biographical Note
Alpha Boubacar
Diallo is a development economist. He is currently the
Coordinator of UNDP's Regional Project:
"Socio-Economic Impact of HIV/AIDS in Sub-Saharan
Africa". He was the Coordinator of the Second
Mission of Identification for Safer Motherhood in
Senegal. Mr. Diallo has also worked as a Senior Economic
Advisor with the Ministry of Economic Development and
Planning in his native country, Guinea. His professional
expertise includes: organizational oevelopment,
experiential training methodologies, management training
for public health officers, programme development and
operational research.
Home
|