Rebeca Grynspan: European Launch of the 2013 Human Development Report

09 Apr 2013

CHECK AGAINS DELIVERY

Presentation by
Rebeca Grynspan
UN Under-Secretary-General and UNDP Associate Administrator
On the Launch of the 2013 Human Development Report
The Rise of the South: Human Progress in a Diverse World
Vienna, Austria
9 April, 2013

SLIDE 1: HDR COVER

Thank you Ambassador Linhart for your kind introduction and Ambassador Kyrle, Secretary General for Foreign Affairs of Austria. 

Dr Lopatka, distinguished guests, I am delighted to be here in Vienna to launch the 2013 Human Development Report - The Rise of the South: Human Progress in a Diverse World.  This Report examines our fast-changing world – in terms of new actors and trends – and the implications for development. 

I would like to thank the Austrian government for hosting this event, and thank Austria too for its dedication to multilateralism and global development.

I am also honoured to present this report on such a distinguished panel.  Indeed I should make particular mention of my fellow panelist, Professor Wolfgang Lutz, one of the world’s greatest demographers, who has been closely involved in this report and the analysis which underpins it. 

This Report, the 22nd in the Human Development global series, has two key messages I want to focus on:

  • First, that the transformation of many developing countries into dynamic major economies with growing political influence and innovative social policies, is having a significant positive impact on human development progress around the world.  Today we would like to highlight this progress, so we can re-double our commitment to development cooperation and value how much has been achieved.
  • Second, that this positive trend and impact will be difficult to sustain without new thinking, particularly around sustainability and equity, and global governance arrangements. And that we have a responsibility to achieve the remaining challenges and support the efforts of the millions of people still waiting for an opportunity to take their families out of poverty and discrimination to build more fair, equal, and rights-based societies.

SLIDE 2 – GLOBAL REBALANCING

The Rise of the South
We stand at a tipping point in global history.   For the first time in 150 years the combined economic output of the three major economies from the South – Brazil, China, and India – is now about equal to that of six large economies from the North in terms of purchasing power parity (PPP). 

By 2020, according to projections developed for the Report, the combined economic output of these three leading developing countries will surpass the aggregate production of the United States, Germany, the United Kingdom, France, Italy, and Canada.  And by 2050 those same three countries are predicted to have double the output of those 6 northern countries, again, in terms of PPP.

A significant amount of this dynamism is being driven by trade, foreign direct investment, and technology partnerships within the South itself. But is also part of the Globalization dynamic since this phenomenon has happen together with a trend towards more and more open economies, not with inward looking development, although some re-balancing has to take place now.

SLIDE 3: NEW PATTERNS OF TRADE

The South–South share of merchandise world trade, for example, has increased from less than eight per cent in 1980 to more than twenty five per cent in 2011, with particularly remarkable growth happening in the last decade.

Innovation and entrepreneurship in the South is also expanding as the Report notes.  And more policy options and solutions to development challenges are coming from within the South itself, making the recognized truth that "there is no one size fits all" solutions to development clearer and more concrete.

SLIDE 4: MIDDLE CLASS EXPANSION

But these changes go well beyond changes to economies.   They encompass genuine human development.  Across every continent, living conditions and the prospects of millions of people have been lifted.

As standards of living have risen worldwide, the global middle class has grown, defined as those earning or spending $10 to $100 per capita per day. By 2030, today’s developing countries will be home to more than four-fifths of the world’s middle class.   And a growing middle class means a growing number who expect better education and health care, better services, and who demand more effective and accountable governments.

As this slide shows, the Asia-Pacific region is leading the charge. By 2020 it will be home to about half of the world’s middle class.  By 2030 two in three middle class people will live in the region. 

Simultaneously, rapid technology diffusion, including information and communication technologies, is enabling much greater numbers of people to interact across borders, and share their expectations with the rest of the world.

The Report argues that this increased connectivity has both economic and political implications.  From cellular banking, which is both cheaper and easier than traditional banking, to a growing global civil-society network advocating for different development issues from climate change,  to political action (Arab Spring).      

SLIDE 5: RAPID HUMAN DEVELOPMENT

Rapid Human Development Progress
It is not enough simply to describe the Rise of the South and observe these trends, however. The challenge is to understand the drivers of what is happening in order to accelerate human development progress in more countries.  The 2013 Report contributes to this by:

  • documenting the current status of human development progress, including persisting inequalities, exclusion and discrimination which reduce the pace of human development; and
  • reviewing the experiences of countries which made stronger progress than expected in their HDI scores between 1990 and 2012, to inform policy choices elsewhere.

The Report finds that over the last decades almost all countries have lifted human development according to the Human Development Index (HDI). This reflects significant advances in education, health, and income across the globe. Indeed, since 1990, all but two countries – namely Zimbabwe and Lesotho - have made notable improvements in their HDI score.  We should celebrate this.

SLIDE 6: Inequality-adjusted HDI

Inequities persist between and within countries.
Progress has been uneven.  For instance, the Report shows that:

  • Average Gross National Income in the group of very high HDI countries is more than twenty times that of low HDI countries; 
  • Life expectancy is more than a third longer in the very high HDI countries than in the low HDI countries with more extreme values at either end (for example 81 years or more in Austria, Japan and Switzerland compared to less than 50 years in Chad, the Central African Republic, Afghanistan, and more); and
  • A child  in a high HDI country can expect to spend almost twice as long in school as one from a low HDI country (again the range is much greater at the country level - for example reaching 15.3 years in Austria and almost 20 years in Australia, but only 4.5 in Sudan and 4.6 in Eritrea);

And within countries gross inequalities persist so in 2010 additional indices were developed to complement the HDI’s power in explaining inequality, deprivation and exclusion, the so called “missing dimensions” of the HDI. And go beyond the calculation of the HDI as a national average of human development achievements, The Inequality-adjusted HDI (IHDI) tries to capture the ‘loss’ in potential human development due to inequality reflecting inequality in each dimension of the HDI :  life expectancy, schooling, and income.  For the 132 countries for which data was available for 2012, the average loss to HDI due to inequality was 23 per cent.  

Reviewing trends for 66 countries since 1990 in the inequality adjusted HDI (IHDI), this graph shows that on average countries lost some 28 percent of their HDI value to inequality. Over time, income inequality increased offsetting the inequality declined in health and education.

This year’s data on the Gender Inequality Index (GII), which reflects gender-based disadvantage in three dimensions – reproductive health, empowerment, and the labour market, suggests that the average loss in achievements (in dimensions of the index) was 46.7 percent.

Finally, the Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) recognizes that poverty is not only about inadequate income, and examines deprivations at the household level across the three dimensions of the HDI (living standards, health, and education) and their overlap. Using this measure, the report finds that 1.56 billion people are living in multi-dimensional poverty, a significantly larger number than 1.14 billion estimated using the $1.25/day value.

Yet, the story of the Rise of the South told in this Report is one of optimism.  It not just about Brazil, China, and India, but about more than forty countries which made stronger progress than expected in their HDI scores between 1990 and 2012, and about how more countries can accelerate progress into the future.

The Report pays particular attention on eighteen countries to describe their diverse paths to success, demonstrating that rapid people-centered development can take root in many places – in countries with very different histories; with very different starting points; and with different natural resources. 

This includes a diverse set of high-achievers countries, big and small, and from all regions of the world: Ghana and Uganda in Sub-Saharan Africa; Bangladesh and India in South Asia; Tunisia from the Arab States; China, Indonesia and Viet Nam in East Asia; and Brazil, Chile and Mexico in Latin America.

By looking in depth at these countries, the Report identifies three key factors contributing to fast progress:

  • a strong, proactive, state focused on development;
  • successfully tapping global markets while simultaneously pursuing inclusive growth; and
  • benefiting from innovative social policies.

Our analysis confirms a message found in every Human Development Report: economic growth does not automatically translate into human development.  Significant investments in people - in education and skills, and in nutrition and health, are vital. I say “investments” because spending money in this way should be seen as an investment, not as a cost.

So sustained rapid growth requires substantial levels of public investment, not just in infrastructure but also in social policy, particularly in health and education.

At the same time successful countries have recognized that growth must be inclusive if it is to be sustained.  We also see a virtuous circle that combines growth, job and work creation and reducing inequality.

The Report focuses heavily on the importance of social policies noting a range of success stories

  • Innovative social protection programs, including cash-transfer programs such as Oportunidades in Mexico and Bolsa Familiar in Brazil have helped improve conditions for poor and marginalized groups, narrowing gaps in income, health, and education and therefore reducing inequalities. In fact, while income inequality has increased in recent years in many parts of the world, including the North, it has declined for the majority of Latin American countries.
  • Ghana and Indonesia invested in high quality education systems. Mexico and Rwanda boosted healthcare. And Brazil, India and China, although in different ways and scopes, built broad-based systems to protect the most vulnerable and boost development.

Sustaining the Momentum
But past successes are no guarantee for the future.  The key question for the globe now, both North and South, is how can we sustain human development for generations to come?

The report deals with a range of challenges, and suggests four priority areas for sustaining the momentum, namely:

  • managing demographic change;
  • confronting environmental pressures;
  • promoting equity and fighting exclusion and discrimination, including between men and women; Excess inequality is bad not just for the poor.  It is bad for everyone. 
  • and, enabling greater voice and participation of citizens, including youth.

 Allow me to briefly touch on each of these.

In countries with rapidly growing populations, pressure on infrastructure, resources, and ecosystems must be managed.  In other countries whose populations are rapidly aging, challenges include finding the resources needed to care for the elderly.  But, as the Report argues, demography is not destiny. Countries can benefit from a so-called “demographic dividend” as their share of working-age population rises. For this, good education and labor policies are critical to ensure young people entering the labour force can find decent work. And policies supporting the care economy and women’s integration to the labour market and paid work are also key!

Indeed I must pay tribute here to the work of my fellow panelist, Professor Wolfgang Lutz, who made a major contribution to the analysis in the report. Much of our understanding of the demographic trends, and their links to education, is based on Wolfgang’s pioneering work. This in turn has profound implications for job creation and service provision right around the world.

The Report also recognizes the risks to global development from environmental threats. These risks impact on us all, but are greater for those countries with the least capacity to adapt, and for the poorest within them.  Climate change is already intensifying environmental threats and impacting on people’s livelihoods.

SLIDE 7: IMPACT OF ENVIRONMET ON POVERTY

The Report points to the high cost of inaction: it predicts that an additional 3 billion people could live in extreme poverty by 2050 if the worst environmental scenario materializes.  Specifically, as shown in this graph, adding 1 billion poor to both Sub Saharan Africa and Asia, which in the baseline cases would have seen the number of people living in poverty drop.  It therefore calls for greater ambition and commitment to tackling environmental degradation.

Third, the Report argues that promoting greater equity is not only an important goal in its own right: it is also central to lifting human development.  It is vital for stability and sustainability. Indeed, an analysis of 132 developed and developing countries for this Report, finds an inverse relationship between inequality and improvement in human development. In other words, inequality slows development and we know that Governments that do not respond to citizens’ needs and to widen opportunities for inclusive growth and political participation, risk losing their legitimacy.   

The Rise of the South and Global Structures and Development
Moving beyond policy recommendations at the country level, a clear message of the Report is that the Rise of the South has implications for global governance and decision making, as well as for how development is financed. 

It argues that as the planet becomes increasingly interconnected – through trade, migration, information and communications technologies, and more – and emerging development challenges cross national boundaries, coordinated action and greater co-operation between North and South is required to tackle them successfully. 

For this, the 2013 Report argues that global governance arrangements must be updated.  Arrangements are needed which are legitimate, accountable, and transparent, so these institutions can be held to account. They need to recognize also the changing geopolitics and give greater voice to countries of the South.

The Report challenges the international community to take ongoing discussions on reform of global institutions and to consider new and innovative ways to better engage the South (some, for example, propose a revitalized South Commission, and stronger regional institutions, but no doubt this discussion is not settled yet). 

In this regard, however, it calls for “coherent pluralism”, namely that the proliferation of agreements at the regional or sub-regional levels should be done in a way which is complementary to global multilateral initiatives, and strengthen collective action to tackle global challenges.

SLIDE 8 - $10 TRILLION FOR INVESMENT

Equally, the Report argues that the South itself can be a powerful force in global development, as countries in the developing world are not only major trade and investment partners for other developing countries, but are increasingly also providers of South-South development co-operation.

Very substantial foreign exchange reserves are held by developing countries for example.  Some two-thirds of the world’s $10.2 trillion – and about three-quarters of the $4.3 trillion in assets controlled by sovereign wealth funds worldwide - are in the South. Prudent investment of these resources can make a considerable contribution to human development.

SLIDE 9: COVER

Conclusion
This Report on the Rise of the South comes at the very time when the international community is considering what the post-2015 development agenda might look like, and the sustainable development goals.

I hope this Report will be seen as valuable to this process and other conversations, as it refreshes our understanding of the current state of global development and demonstrates how much can be learned from the successes of the South. 

The challenge now – for UNDP, for Austria, for everyone - is to maintain progress, but to do so by creating a balance between social and economic policies, and within the boundaries set by nature.

We must capitalize on the growing influence of the South and on the global cooperation between all countries to propel our world

Leadership
Rebeca

Rebeca Grynspan was appointed by Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon to the position of UN Under-Secretary-General and UNDP Associate Administrator effective 1 February, 2010. Before joining the United Nations, Ms. Grynspan was elected Vice-President of Costa Rica from 1994 to 1998.

More
Download the report
Rise of the South: Human Progress in a Diverse World

More than 40 developing countries have made greater human development gains in recent decades than would have been predicted.

 

View all HDR reports